
Yeah, this entry is really late, even later than the Spain entries, which were quite late, but it still has to be written. Just allow yourself to be taken back to the heady days of August 2007. We'd just returned from Spain and, settling in at work, I fired up Gothamist and saw an announcement that the Rentals would be playing at the Nokia Theatre that night. Whoa, the Rentals?! As Scott later said, I didn't even know the Rentals were still a band, let alone playing shows. The project by Matt Sharp of Weezer was one of the few remaining bands that I loved in my youth but had never seen live. In fact I had hardly ever heard of them ever playing any shows, though Scott had seen Sharp play a hazy solo show when he was doing country stuff.
But wow, did I want to see them. The Rentals' first album, Return of the Rentals (1995), was a wonderful pop confection. The lyrics were nothing profound or strongly emotional, but the melodies and vocal harmonies were brilliant, and in my opinion the pervasive use of the Moog was pretty creative; it was a nice change in timbre from the usual distorted guitar.
The second album, 1999's Seven More Minutes, was a document of Sharp's time in Barcelona. The music is a bit stranger and more powerful. The lyrics are musings on ambiguous relationships and taking it easy, and odes to a life in Spain that couldn't last very long. There are a lot of guest spots: Damon Albarn of Blur, Donna Matthews of Elastica, and the album often sounds like a party, though it was recorded in London over the course of two years, with different people dropping by now and then to contribute. The record is for me a perfect evocation of the idealized Europe, and it means a lot to me even though I've never experienced it at all the way he did.
So my thoughts after reading about the show, in rapid succession, were... damnit! Why do I always hear about the shows the very day they're happening? And then...could tickets still be available? What the hell is the Nokia Theatre?
Fortunately, I wasn't the only one who had forgotten The Rentals were even a band, and tickets were still available at the box office after work. I had gotten in touch with Scott, and he had agreed to come along. The Nokia Theatre turned out to be a somewhat bizarre proposition: a spotless venue underneath Times Square, featuring spacious carpeted hallways and colored lighting, cell phones in display cases, and a concession stand with brownies and sandwiches. It felt more like a movie theater than a place to see a rock show, but I have to admit some things about it were a clear improvement. We could sit down on the ground without being trampled or getting filthy. And the floor in the concert room was split-leveled, so that we could stand pretty far back from the stage and still have a great view. We spent the opening band's set sitting down looking at photos on my laptop, and when it was time for The Rentals, it almost felt like cheating to be seeing them without having suffered on any long lines or stood in a sweaty, violent crowd for hours.
When they came out, the only member I recognized other than Sharp was Rachel Haden, but that was to be expected after so long. The band was tight, and the sound was extremely clean, almost too clean in that it put the performances under a microscope. But it was great to be able to hear vocals so clearly with a band that uses them so well. The set was well chosen, and included the majority of both albums and a couple of new songs. Matt Sharp was animated but geeky as ever, frequently making big enthusiastic gestures or pretending he was being blown backward. Some other highlights for me:
- Finally understanding the lyrics to the song "Barcelona" (I had never bothered to look them up)
- Petra Haden's cameo and vocals on "Friends of P." She was hit by a car in 2000 and suffered debilitating injuries and a coma. I had no idea it was that long ago already, but it was still good to see her in good health.
- They played "I Just Threw out the Love of My Dreams", which was originally released as a Weezer b-side to "The Good Life" but was sung by Rachel Haden and has a strong Rentals sound to it.
The ending of the show was bizarre as well. As they started to play a second song during the encore, an employee of the venue ran onto the stage, angrily shouting "No!" and started disconnecting the instruments from the amplifiers. At one point he rubbed his fingers together, giving the sign for money. Matt Sharp shrugged and said "there's nothing we can do," and the band trudged offstage. We speculated that the issue was overtime pay for the venue's employees, but it was only 11pm, and given that I've never seen this happen before in a dozen years of attending shows, it seemed unnecessary. Perhaps this was the inevitable crack in the Nokia Theatre's sterile veneer, but it couldn't ruin a great time that I would never have imagined happening twelve hours earlier.
