May 2, 2006
Looking For: DVDs with emotional talking heads
I've been interested for a few years, on and off, in the work of Paul Ekman. He did a lot of research into how our faces react to our emotions. He discovered that the meaning of emotional facial expressions is universal across cultures. He contends that there are facial expressions we are not conscious of and that most of us never notice in others--very subtle ones, and also very quick ones that flash across the face in a fraction of a second as a first emotional response to a situation--and that we can learn to see these and use them to tell when someone is hiding their true feelings.
There was a great New Yorker profile by Malcom Gladwell in 2002 that's available at his site. Jordan initially showed it to me that year, and I could not resist trying to learn to see microexpressions and read faces. This entails learning the muscles of the face and the combinations of their exercise that produce familiar facial expressions, of which Ekman has produced an encyclopaedia called FACS (Facial Action Coding System). It also requires learning about how the expressions and muscle movements correspond to emotions. This knowledge is not included in FACS because it is still under research, and FACS is in fact a kit for carrying out that research by laying out a system for quantifying the expressions observed by researchers. Finally it requires learning to see the microexpressions that supposedly come and go from a face within a fifth of a second or so.
So the question for me became what can I buy or do to learn this, preferably without spending a lot of money, but spending as much time as necessary. The complete FACS sells for $260, which I might be able to justify to myself at some point, but I really wanted to see if I could achieve my goals for less. A couple of years ago I bought two CD-ROMs that Ekman sells, called the "Micro-Expression Training Tool" and the "Subtle Expression Training Tool" for $30 each. The titles are self-explanatory, but I found them lacking. In the "METT", you're shown pictures of people with neutral faces, and then a photo of them making an expression is flashed on for some short interval, then the original picture is back, and you're tested on what emotion they were showing in the quick photo. After that initial quiz you get to look at the expression photos for a longer time, and then you take the test again. You do better, so you must be able to see micro-expressions! Not quite. One sample per emotion is really not enough to help you learn the essence of the expression. More importantly, seeing a quick photo flashed in this way is very different from how it must look when someone really makes a microexpression. Even one quick video would have been so helpful, and would be the most convincing evidence I've seen yet that the phenomenon really exists. This was like trying to learn a foreign language with a list of 10 words translated.
Since then I found this site (warning: silly music) which has a wealth of information related to FACS, including material about the facial muscles and videos of people moving those specific muscles. You can also download some sample chapters from the full FACS. With that and Ekman's book "Emotions Revealed", which I've finally started reading, I feel like I'm starting to get a better foundation for observing faces in the wild.
In the New Yorker profile, Silvan Tomkins is described as perhaps the best face reader the world has ever known. He learned the skill by watching television with the sound turned down. I don't have cable TV right now, but I do have access to DVDs through Netflix, and that's where I finally come to my point. To practice observing faces, I'd like to be able to watch DVDs with the sound off and watch the faces of people, and then if necessary go back and watch it with the sound on to see if I can correctly predict the emotions they were experiencing at that time. I can also slow the action down to try to get a better look at fleeting microexpressions. To be precise, this is what I'm looking for:
- Lots of close-up shots of people's faces that don't cut away a lot.
- The people could be expected to be experiencing some kind of emotion, and preferably a range of emotions.
- Non-fiction is preferred--since microexpressions are supposed to be subconscious, I don't know if even a good actor's expressions would correspond more to their character's situation or to how filming was going that day.
I think that about covers it. The first requirement might be the hardest to fulfill, because it goes against a very common style of documentary. But I know there must be some good stuff out there, it's just hard to get a feel for how well a DVD will meet my requirements without actually seeing it. Anyone have any ideas?




