July 8, 2005
The Baxter
Okay, time to get things going around here.
First off, a few weeks ago I saw The Baxter, the new movie by Michael Showalter, at the free 'Drive-in Movies' event at Rockefeller Center. The setup was pretty neat, with seats in the Promenade area looking at a screen across the ice rink. The contrast on the picture wasn't great, but what can you expect. The sound was better than average for outdoors, with small speakers placed throughout the seating area.
Before the movie started, Showalter, David Wain, and Michael Ian Black came up on a stage to do a little performance. They also called up fellow The State alumni Joe Lo Truglio and Ken Marino, and Wet Hot American Summer guy A.D. Miles. The performance was basically banter about the movie and Stella, followed by a Q&A that just left me embarrassed for most of the questioners. Someone asked what we all really wanted to know, when The State DVD is coming out, and the answer: they just don't know.
As for the movie, I'd hate to be overly critical of the work of someone who really deserves all their success and more, but to me it was lacking in one thing that makes much of The State, Wet Hot, and Stella funny: mocking our banal, affected interactions by introducing the absurd into them. Before seeing it I'd read in a Gothamist interview about how it was very different from all the other stuff, an old-fashioned kind of movie with no profanity or gross-out humor. That seemed fine, and the premise, about the guy who is always the wrong guy for a girl and gets dumped for the more exciting guy who can sweep her off her feet, seemed very promising. But I think they needed to go further with the old-fashioned theme to get any comedic value out of it, for example by using Mr. Burns-esque antiquated phrases for modern things. And the premise was not quite what I thought it was: instead of being the nice guy who gets dumped for a dashing jerk, Showalter's character is just a truly boring guy who doesn't seem desirable, or very sympathetic, at all.
Despite its being an indie production, the movie seemed to suffer from some of the same faults as so many Hollywood romantic comedies. All the emotions and characters were pretty shallow. Plot points were whisked along with hardly any explanation. (Showalter's main girl decides to date him and then to marry him in the space of a scene in which they meet, and then a brief montage. She freaks out and leaves him because he doesn't take seriously a form about what kind of music and food they want at their wedding. When he next sees her at a hotel she has checked into, that conflict seems to have been instantly resolved.) There were bizarre and unnecessary holes in the script, as when an employee shows up for a stint of temp work in Showalter's office, and then after a three-minute conversation announces that she has to go because she's leaving town. I guess that's the nature of temp work.
The only thing I could think of to explain such deficiencies in a movie by someone who obviously isn't in a position to be tossing out a clearly crappy project just for money, is that perhaps the whole thing is a parody of all the bad things about generic romantic comedies. When I read the descriptions in the above paragraph it starts to sound that way. But the movie really didn't seem to be playing it that way--if it was the intention, it was done way too generally to produce any specific moments at which you could laugh at that. More likely it seems like a slightly desperate bid for wider success by dumbing down for the masses. I didn't really want to ask that question when walking by him afterward ("So...this was all a big joke right? You can't be serious...right?"). Then again while walking to the subway I did overhear someone say "Yeah, I liked that way more than Wet Hot American Summer," so maybe the strategy will work!
One final comment, there was a musical motif in the movie that I could swear was very very similar to one in another recent movie. It was a melancholy, repetitive little melody, with an organ-like instrument playing a three-note sequence at three different starting positions, and a more bell-like instrument doing a 4-note descending line at the end of each phrase. I think the movie I'm remembering it from was either Adaptation or Eternal Sunshine, but I'll have to rewatch them to see. If anyone else sees this movie and has a similar thought please let me know.
On a better note, I'm pleasantly surprised by the one episode I've seen so far of the Stella TV show. The transition from the incredibly vulgar shorts on the DVD I have to the relative cleanliness of Comedy Central, as well as the more cohesive plots within a half-hour episode, was made more gracefully than I would have thought possible, and it was very funny.






