Tonight as I was walking home, I heard a voice behind me say "say excuse me." At first thought someone giving an etiquette lecture, but then I realized it had been "say, excuse me." A guy was trying to get my attention, using a rather outdated phrasing. He was in his mid to late thirties, white, reasonably well dressed, with no discernable accent. I turned and he continued "I'm not trying to bother you.." and proceeded to explain that he had just been drinking at a bar and someone had walked off with his laptop bag, which contained his money, credit/bank cards and car keys as well as his laptop. He had already filled out a police report and everything. He pointed to his car right across the street, "the black one," saying he was from New Jersey and needed to get back there to get his spare set of car keys, to retrieve his car.
In the midst of this the man told me several biographical details, to make sure I understood what an upstanding fellow he was. An MBA from Wharton, works at Oppenheimer Fund. He said "I'm a really ethical guy" at one point. He asked me where I was from. I said "right around here" and he replied "right on." The skin of his hands was somewhat rough.
By this point it was pretty probable that I would try to give him whatever he needed, because I don't think too well in these situations, and I'd rather simply give it to him even if I get screwed than try to come up with some explanation for why I don't want to, and feel guilty afterward. So I said "what do you need?" meaning how much, but he interpreted it more generally and said "just some help..." I was so surprised to hear that as a euphemism for money from an (apparent) non-panhandler that for a moment I thought he actually wanted me to do something for him, but then he continued "about $8 for a train, a bus, to get back to Fort Lee..." I reached into my pocket and had a twenty and two singles. Damn, $8 I really wouldn't have cared much about but losing $20 kind of sucks. But I gave it to him, along with my name and phone number, and he assured me that he would call me in about 45 minutes when he got home so we could arrange a time and place to meet so he could return it to me. He used the word "usurious" to describe the amount he would be willing to give me back. Then he looked at my name and asked if I was Jewish and I said "well, sort of...not really practicing, you know." He said he was too, but also not practicing, he thanked me profusely, and with that we parted.
So, either he's honest, he's a panhandler or otherwise poor guy and pathological liar who uses this to get a quick buck and has polished his performance, or he's a more sophisticated con man who doesn't really need the money but doesn't mind getting it anyway. I'm inclined to discout the last possibility, because in the grand scheme of things it was such a small sum. I also doubt that any con man worth his salt would say something like "I'm a really ethical guy," or indeed use such a blunt game as this. The second possibility is...a possibility, and doesn't necessarily conflict with the intelligence that his speech pattern seemed to indicate.
After about four hours there had been no phone call, so out of curiosity I went to see if the car he pointed out was still there. If it was, of course, that didn't give me any real indication, as it could never have been his in the first place. But if it was gone, I could at least stop waiting for the phone to ring. The car was indeed still there. It had a New York license plate, which doesn't bother me too much: it's plausible, and unless he was really desperate and amateur, there was no good reason for him not to check that out beforehand. Then again, he might have decided that unless I was rude and checked it out before giving him anything, he could probably have gotten away by the time I could check it out.
Other than the absence of a phone call, honesty doesn't seem too out of the question. It's understandable that would have chosen me to ask, not because I look like a sucker necessarily, but because I look like a peer. His manner was fitting for someone who has just had a lot stolen, but is more frustrated than truly damaged by it, and is still thinking rationally. Also, the 'drinking at a bar' part of the story is one that a grifter trying to appear as virtuous as possible would probably not think to include. It's still plausible that it took a lot longer than planned to get home, and that he thought it would be too late for me to meet tonight. But I won't hold my breath. I probably will, however, check for the car tomorrow morning, because being on an avenue, if it isn't retrieved it's liable to be ticketed or towed.
In retrospect I probably should have at least asked for his phone number, although again it wouldn't have been too hard for him to make one up.
On tonight's syndicated episode of Futurama, Fry and Leela were walking down the street and a ragged man jumped out of an alley and said, "Please help me! Someone stole all my money and I need to get back to Jersey City where uh, my mother is dying...so I'm mugging you!"